requests raise questions
about need for public art policy
Chautauqua to help
create a Bicentennial mural
(September 2008) Recent requests brought before
the Madison Historic District Board of Review regarding building murals
has prompted a debate about whether the city of Madison needs a public
The issue first arose at the boards July meeting when two separate
requests for public murals were presented. Board members told the applicants
that there is no policy governing public art in the community. A discussion
ensued among board members about whether they need one to help guide
them if faced with future problems.
The board governs the citys Historic District ordinance, which
aims to protect the oldest and most historic part of the city of Madison.
Mural requests in the past have been directed to the board because of
its responsibility in governing the ordinance, which guides owners of
historic structures on issues concerning the exteriors of their buildings.
More murals are coming into play. The city should adopt some type
of public art policy to help govern any issues that could arise,
said Rich Murray, a board member who is also the president of the local
preservationist organization Cornerstone Society. When something
is in place, its appearance affects the downtown area.
He suggested a possible arts advisory commission set in place by the
city for future public art proposals. Any type of public art policy
would have to be implemented by the city, he said. There
is a wealth of artists in this community that could give valuable insight
into such a policy or serve on a committee for it.
Madison Chautauqua Festival of Arts Coordinator Georgie Kelly was one
of the people who requested permission to put up a mural in downtown
Madison. The Madison Chautauqua committee wants to give the city a Bicentennial
mural to be put in place by summer 2009, when the city marks the anniversary
of its founding.
Kelly said there will be a competition that should begin in November
in which area artists submit designs that have a theme of historic
Madison. A winning submission will be chosen by a committee of
artists led by Hanover, Ind.s Bill Borden, a well-known and well-respected
Once the design has been selected, a group of 10 artists will be selected
to produce sections of that design, using the medium they are comfortable
with, to create the whole art piece. We are hoping for a quilt
affect that will be both unique and interesting, said Kelly.
Each piece will then be digitally photographed, enlarged and put on
vinyl. The entire mural will be hung in place in a dedication ceremony
in June 2009 and will stay in place for one year. We will then
revisit whether the mural should stay up or possibly be moved,
said Kelly. The actual site for the Bicentennial mural has not yet been
determined, but there are several buildings being considered.
We went before the board of review as a courtesy and for their
support; we knew the board does not have guidelines for public art,
said Kelly. She believes a public art policy would be appropriate because
of the culture of our community.
We are a historic town that is also family-oriented. Some types
of art would be found offensive in our tight community, she said.
A public art policy would guide artists as to what would work
for our community members.
Murray echoed that sentiment. Art is subjective, he said.
What one thinks is attractive, others detest. An art policy would
hopefully resolve any of those types of conflicts before they became
a public issue.
Tiffany Black, a recent Hanover College graduate and artist, has created
a design proposal for a mural that will be applied to the exterior wall
of Shipleys Tavern, 322 W. Main St., once adequate funding has
been raised. She plans to use a steamboat and historic river scene in
her mural because they play a prominent role in Madisons history.
Other historic landmarks in Madison will surround the river scene.
She believes a public art policy would benefit area artists. When
I decided to do this, I wasnt sure how to begin or who to even
talk to, she said. A public art policy would hopefully offer
guidelines with steps on how to proceed with a project. It would also
alleviate any problems or potential conflicts before they arise.
Shipleys building owner Cris Sauer, however, had a different view.
When he sought approval for the mural, he was told by the citys
zoning officials that he needed to present his proposal before the Historic
District Board of Review. I think I should be able to decide what
I put on my own building, he said. After all, I am the one
who pays for the upkeep, taxes and all other financial aspects of my
Black is still seeking sponsors for the mural on Shipleys Tavern.
Sponsors will have their names written into the mural.
For more information about the Shipleys
Tavern mural, contact Tiffany Black at (317) 796-8793. Artists interested
in the Madison Chautauqua Bicentennial Mural may contact Georgie Kelly
at (812) 265-6100.
Back to September 2008